Exploring Controlled Articular Rotations (CARs)
Controlled Articular Rotations (CARs) are the entrance point to Dr. Andreo Spina’s Functional Range Conditioning system:
They are meant to:
1. assess joint health (particularly the function of the deep joint capsule)
2. maintain outer ranges of motion
3. rehabilitate through anti-inflammatory movement
ASSESSING JOINT HEALTH
Before beginning, we cannot assume a joint lives in neutral. Axial rotational positioning has an influence on perceived flexion, extension, and abduction and adduction. They don’t simply take the joints through these planes of motion — they alter the brain’s recognition of where a ‘normal start’ resides:
Elevation and/or depression is a sign that a joint is not centrated. Rotation without centration will just exacerbate issues. Shoulders, for example, tend to shift anteriorly from being held in a rounded forward posture. Hanging from a bar helps center the glenohumeral joint in its socket. Gravity pulls the body straight down, opening the shoulders and shifting the humerus back into the glenoid cavity.
The capsule is the deepest part of a joint. It is first to report to the CNS. In assessing the capsule we can assess the joint and its function in individual degrees of freedom (or stickiness).
When circling, pinch points are a sign of joint issue. Where the pinch point(s) lies in relationof the direction of the circle dictates whether the problem is tissue-based or biomechanically-based.
yellow: direction of the circle
red: opening angle (gets bigger) = restrictive tissue
green: closing angle (gets smaller) = moving/working tissue
An opening angle pinch signals a tissue problem. Work through it. A closing angle pinch indicates there is a biomechanical problem. There is a structural or neurological glitch. Forcing it can cause further damage. Specific stretching or release would be the protocol. In general, keeping a slow, steady speed ensures that you are in control. Loosen the tension as you come across a speed bump and continue through with deliberate practice.
MAINTAIN OUTER RANGES OF MOTION
Joint rotations can be done in a multitude of ways, not just those promoted by the FRC system. Here Emmet Louis gives his take on a full body sequence:
The body adapts to the demands placed against it. The adage of if you don’t use it, you lose it, applies directly here. Likewise, if you’ve lost it, it will take time and effort to regain it. Remember how long and little it took to escape you. Consistency is the key to regaining and keeping function. #almosteverydamnday. (I am nothing if not honest).
It is important to point out that the limbs are translations of the spine. Asserting your control over your neck and spine before moving to the joints of the arms and legs will go a long way in ensuring work gets put in where work is needed. (A thorough how-to can be found in the link).
Tension and Irradiation
The idea behind tensing every one of your joints/muscles except the one your are moving is meant to isolate the joint and promote articular independence. Control means just that — how well can you get a single joint to do what you want it to do without influence or interference from other joint(s). Assessments tend to start with low irradiation, 30% or less. When you ramp up the tension, though, the test becomes a workout. It’s hard to squeeze every single one of your muscles AND control the movement of a joint. Once you move through about 70% tension, the moving part itself gets bogged down, as if it was moving through a thick fluid. There is a huge distinction between a free flowing joint and a joint you are providing resistance to. The former is to test a joint and the latter is to work the joint through larger and larger circles.
The Role of Gravity
Gravity is the one constant load being placed upon our bodies. When manipulating it, we must consider how we usually hold ourselves (how it typically acts upon us) and which muscles of the joint we wish to put more stress on. More work will be done by whichever muscles are placed against the pull of gravity.
Here’s an upright version of glenohumeral CARs with a focus on the superior shoulder:
One from quadruped position focusing on the posterior muscles of the back:
And one from a supine position focusing on the anterior shoulder and chest:
Lying down instead of being supported by our limbs helps force the core musculature to drive the movement.
Hinge joints of the elbow and knee are particularly difficult to isolate. Mid-joints, by design, should be intricately connected to those above and below. Working them in isolation can be tricky. You have to consider the flexion-extension implications of the movement.
Here’s a bit of a figure-8 as shown here with the elbow:
Keeping the shoulder pinned to the body helps keep glenohumeral rotation out of it. Also locking the hand (performed in nuetral instead of a balled fist to maximize ‘natural’ position behind the back) helps deter wrist involvement.
Another option is to use lateral movement of the distal joint to see how that effects flexion and extension:
Finally, consider the placement of the proximal joint (hip or shoulder) and how the musculature responds:
Gravity AND position play a role in this hamstring dominated movement.
One simple thought here — get the joint moving in the direction of the injury as soon as possible. Injury equals restriction, and if hypermobilizing a joint in one direction (and under load) caused harm, we must remind the brain as soon as possible that we still want it to go there; that movement in this direction is normal and OK. As it heals, then, cells will be laid down that understand what they are supposed to do. There’s less convincing and compensation that occurs once load is applied, quickening a return back to functional.
- CARs are meant to be performed under consistent speed and smoothness
- Do not assume that a joint ‘sits’ in neutral
- Assessments go after the joint capsule
- Evaluate the neck and spine before going to the limbs
- Manipulate gravity to get at the muscles you desire
- Hinge joints have multiple variables to consider, primarily the placement of proximal and distal joints
- Move a joint in the position of injury as soon as acute healing allows. Apply load as possible.
A COLLECTIVE LIBRARY OF FRC, FIGHTING MONKEY, PRI, & MOVNAT RESOURCES CAN BE FOUND HERE.
Does the pinch point issue only apply to joint circles? What if I’m externally and internally rotating my shoulder?
Also, all the videos are the same.
Nevermind about the videos, that seems to be a browser glitch.
Chris, since internal and external rotation are also rotations (albeit axial ones), I would assume the same ‘pinching’ rules apply: opening angle = work through it, closing angle = adjust ‘what’/ ‘how’ you are moving.
And for labelling the movement as opening or closing, rotating INTO end ROM is closing the joint and rotating FROM end ROM is opening the joint?
So in a single rotation the label would change from opening to closing? And for a concrete example: if I internally rotate my shoulder and it pinches, I need to adjust what I’m doing(*) and if I’m externally rotating from a fully internally rotated position and I feel a pinch it’s a tissue problem and I shoulder work through it?
*: or in my case, release my subscapularis
CHRIS, Opening and closing refers to angles relative to the direction of motion. Arms at sides, if I internally rotate the shoulder, the closing angle is the one getting smaller — the deltoid cap to the collar bone. The opening angle refers to the angle getting bigger — rear delts to shoulder blade. Pinching references occur in the musculature residing in that range. In this example, front of shoulder/pec = closing angle; rear shoulder/back = opening angle. If you were to feel a pinch on the front of the shoulder/pec attatchment area, stop and adjust how you’re doing the movement. This can include manipulating your position against gravity, motor sequencing, adding some sort of assistance/ resistance, etc.
When you use the CARs as an assessment are you looking for a particular ROM? Do you stop at any particular points to check flexion, extension, rotation?
Excellent question, Justin. You could go into ‘therapeutic’ ROM that assigns a number to functional ROM, but I find that those aren’t necessary when comparing pieces to the whole. Does the right look like the left? Are there any pinch points? Does the smoothness or speed become abrupt at certain places? These are the all signs for further investigation… EXACT points in which you would check flexion, extension, and rotation.
In your FRC summary on Reddit you wrote “irradiating tension from that deep gut out to all areas of the body EXCEPT the working joint”. I was confused by this. Does this mean you keep the joint you are working on completely loose the whole time and only tighten everything around it? Are you not supposed to have tension in the CARs joint?
It depends on your intent. If you want motion in a joint it should have minimal tension to create motion, no? On the other hand, if you are trying to build motion in a new range, it will take a whole bunch of work from neighboring tissues to assisting you in getting into that unfamiliar territory. You can also use excessive tension ‘train’ a joint through a range and make it harder (this is the FRC protocol of self-induced tension — “pretend you are moving through water, tar…”), but the overall goal of useable range should be to let it be open for use under any circumstances, not just high-tension, routine, and isolated practice.